Product Information

Product Information

Which would be better to supplement with NR or NAD+?

2025-01-02

First, understand the concepts of NR and NAD+

NR (Nicotinamide ribose):

NR is a derivative of the B3 family of vitamins, which is a precursor substance for NAD + (nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide). This means that the body can use NR to synthesize NAD +. Inside the cell, NR is converted to NAD+ by a series of enzymatic reactions. For example, NR is first phosphorylated in the cell by nicotinamide ribose kinase (NRK), and then undergoes further reaction steps to eventually produce NAD +.

NAD + (nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide):

NAD + is a coenzyme that plays a key role in cellular metabolism. It is involved in a number of important physiological processes, including energy metabolism (e.g., the tricarboxylic acid cycle in cellular respiration, where NAD + accepts electrons and helps produce ATP, the energy currency), DNA repair (it is a substrate for poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase (PARP), which is involved in the repair of DNA damage), and cell signaling.

nr详情(1)

Different effects and benefits of NR and NAD + supplementation

Benefits of NR supplementation:

  • Indirect way to increase NAD+ levels: Since NR is a precursor to NAD+, supplementing with NR can promote the body's own synthesis of NAD+. This is a relatively natural way for the body to synthesize the right amount of NAD+ according to its own needs and regulatory mechanisms. For example, in some animal studies and preliminary human studies, NR supplementation has been found to increase intracellular levels of NAD +, which improves mitochondrial function because NAD + is essential for energy-producing processes in the mitochondria, which may enhance overall energy metabolism, endurance, and athletic performance.

  • Potential Safety Benefits: Because NR is a naturally occurring substance and a member of the vitamin B3 family, supplementation with NR at appropriate doses is generally considered to be relatively safe. Current research has not identified serious side effects, although at high doses it may cause some mild reactions such as flushing and itching, similar to overdosing on vitamin B3.

Benefits of NAD + supplementation:

  • Direct Supplementation of Key Co-Enzymes: Direct supplementation of NAD + can rapidly increase NAD + levels in the body. This may be a more direct and effective approach for some people who suffer from NAD+ deficiency-related diseases or whose NAD+ levels decline dramatically with age. For example, in studies of neurodegenerative diseases such as Alzheimer's disease, where low levels of NAD + have been found in the brains of patients, direct supplementation of NAD + is expected to improve neuronal metabolism and function, thereby alleviating disease symptoms.

  • Targeted intervention in certain disease processes: In terms of DNA repair, direct supplementation of NAD+ can provide sufficient substrate for enzymes involved in DNA repair, such as PARP, and enhance the ability of cells to repair DNA damage. This may be of potential value in the prevention and treatment of diseases caused by the accumulation of DNA damage, such as certain cancers and premature aging.

Limitations and considerations of supplemental NR and NAD+

Limitations of NR supplementation:

  • Conversion Efficiency Issues: Although NR can be converted to NAD +, this conversion process is affected by a variety of factors, including individual genetic differences, the body's metabolic state, etc. Not all ingested NR is efficiently converted to NAD+, which may affect the actual effectiveness of supplementation. For example, some individuals may have a genetic variant that results in lower NRK enzyme activity, which may affect the conversion of NR to NAD +.

  • Takes Time to Work: Because it is an indirect boost to NAD+ levels, it may take time for NAD+ levels to increase after NR supplementation. NR supplementation may not be the best choice for situations where NAD+ levels are urgently needed to improve acute symptoms.

    Limitations of NAD + supplementation:

  • Absorption and Stability Issues: NAD + is a large molecule, and it may face absorption difficulties when supplemented orally. In the gastrointestinal environment, NAD + may be broken down, affecting the amount actually absorbed by the body. There is also a lack of very effective formulations to ensure the stability and longevity of NAD + in the body.

  • Cost factor: Currently, direct NAD + supplementation is relatively expensive, which is a limiting factor for long-term use or large-scale applications.

Conclusion

There are advantages and disadvantages to supplementing with NR and NAD+. If you are looking for a relatively natural and safe way to improve your body's metabolic function and boost NAD+ levels over the long term, then supplementing with NR may be a better option. However, for specific disease conditions, especially those associated with severe NAD+ deficiencies or those that require a rapid increase in NAD+ levels to intervene in the disease process, direct supplementation with NAD+ may be more appropriate under the guidance of a physician. However, both NR and NAD+ supplementation require consideration of individual differences, product quality, and safety, and research in this area is still evolving and improving.


Contact Us

If you have any requirements, please contact us freely and we will provide you the best solution.

Message Us